We can work on Managing Diversity in Work Cultures

In order to compete successfully in world markets, international leaders must be able to understand and manage diversity. That is, they must obtain better knowledge of historical, cultural, and religious forces that motivate and drive people in foreign cultures. In Japan, for example, business relations typically operate within the context of Wa, which means group harmony and social cohesion. In China, business is measured via guanxi, or personal relations. In South Korea, the inhwa concept is employed, which is based on the principles of hierarchical relationships (Alston, 1989). These diverse cultures require international leaders to have a solid grasp of the measures by which business dealings are fostered. Please review and provide your evidence-based rationale regarding the following:

Select two countries of your choice and research their business cultures. Compare and contrast their business cultures with the US business culture. Evaluate the similarities and differences that you find. How should international leaders respond to this diversity within the international work culture?

Explain how awareness of business culture across countries can enhance strategy implementation.

An organization has an aggressive diversity and gender equality program and has decided to send a female senior manager to a subsidiary in another country where women are not treated as equals. Take a position for or against this decision and support your position with reasoned arguments and citations and references to justify your premises.

find the cost of your paper
facebookShare on Facebook

TwitterTweet

FollowFollow us

Sample Answer

 

 

 

Let’s explore business cultures and their impact on international leadership and strategy.

Comparison of Business Cultures: US, Germany, and Brazil

I’ve chosen Germany and Brazil for comparison with the US, highlighting key cultural dimensions that impact business interactions.

United States:

  • Individualism: High emphasis on individual achievement, competition, and self-reliance.
  • Low Power Distance: Relatively flat organizational structures, with less emphasis on hierarchy. Employees expect to have a voice.

 

Full Answer Section

 

 

 

 

  • Short-Term Orientation: Focus on immediate results and quick returns on investment.
  • Masculinity: Achievement-oriented, with a focus on success, competition, and material rewards.
  • Low Uncertainty Avoidance: Comfortable with ambiguity and risk-taking.
  • Linear-Active: Doing one thing at a time, prioritizing schedules and deadlines.

Germany:

  • Individualism: Also individualistic, but with a stronger emphasis on cooperation and consensus-building within teams.
  • Low Power Distance: Similar to the US, but hierarchy is more respected and followed. Decisions often involve consultation but are ultimately made by those in authority.
  • Long-Term Orientation: Emphasis on planning for the future and investing in long-term projects.
  • Masculinity: Achievement-oriented, but with a greater focus on quality and efficiency than outward displays of success.
  • High Uncertainty Avoidance: Preference for clear rules, structure, and detailed planning to minimize uncertainty.
  • Multi-Active (to a lesser extent than Brazil): Can handle multiple tasks simultaneously but with more structure and order than in Brazil.

Brazil:

  • Collectivism: Strong emphasis on family and social groups. Relationships and trust are crucial for conducting business.
  • High Power Distance: Acceptance of hierarchical structures and centralized decision-making. Respect for authority is paramount.
  • Short-Term Orientation: Focus on immediate needs and present opportunities. Time is more fluid, and deadlines can be flexible.
  • Femininity (relatively): Value relationships, cooperation, and quality of life. While achievement is important, it’s not the sole focus.
  • High Uncertainty Avoidance: Preference for established rules and procedures. Ambiguity and change can be uncomfortable.
  • Multi-Active: Comfortable juggling multiple tasks and projects simultaneously. Relationships and flexibility are prioritized over strict adherence to schedules.

Similarities and Differences:

  • Both the US and Germany are relatively individualistic and have low power distance, though Germany has a slightly more hierarchical structure. Brazil, in contrast, is collectivist and has high power distance.
  • The US and Brazil tend to be more short-term oriented, while Germany has a stronger long-term focus.
  • All three cultures are achievement-oriented, but the expression of this achievement varies.
  • Both Brazil and Germany exhibit higher uncertainty avoidance than the US, meaning they are less comfortable with ambiguity.

How International Leaders Should Respond:

International leaders must be culturally intelligent. This involves:

  • Awareness: Understanding their own cultural biases and assumptions.
  • Knowledge: Learning about the specific cultural norms and values of the countries they work in.
  • Skills: Developing the ability to adapt their communication and leadership styles to different cultural contexts.

Specifically, leaders should:

  • Build Relationships: In collectivist cultures like Brazil, prioritize building personal relationships and trust before focusing on business transactions.
  • Communicate Effectively: Adapt communication styles to the specific culture. Direct communication might be appreciated in the US and Germany but could be seen as rude in Brazil.
  • Respect Hierarchy: In high power distance cultures, acknowledge and respect hierarchical structures.
  • Be Flexible: In cultures with fluid time orientations, be prepared for plans to change and deadlines to shift.
  • Seek Local Expertise: Consult with local advisors and partners to gain insights into cultural nuances and navigate business practices effectively.

Enhancing Strategy Implementation through Cultural Awareness:

Cultural awareness is essential for successful strategy implementation. Strategies that are effective in one cultural context may fail miserably in another. For example, a marketing campaign that emphasizes individual achievement might resonate in the US but could fall flat in a collectivist culture. By understanding cultural values and beliefs, international leaders can:

  • Tailor Strategies: Adapt strategies to the specific cultural context, increasing the likelihood of success.
  • Improve Communication: Communicate the strategy effectively to diverse stakeholders, ensuring that the message is understood and accepted.
  • Build Buy-in: Gain buy-in from local employees and partners by involving them in the implementation process and respecting their perspectives.
  • Minimize Resistance: Anticipate and address potential cultural barriers to implementation.

Sending a Female Senior Manager to a Subsidiary with Gender Inequality:

This is a complex ethical dilemma. While the organization’s commitment to diversity and gender equality is commendable, sending a female manager to a subsidiary where women are not treated as equals raises significant concerns.

Arguments Against:

  • Safety and Well-being: The manager’s safety and well-being must be the top priority. Sending her to an environment where she may face discrimination, harassment, or even violence is unethical and irresponsible.
  • Effectiveness: Her ability to be effective in her role could be severely hampered by the cultural context. She may face resistance from local staff and partners, making it difficult for her to achieve her objectives.
  • Symbolic Harm: While the organization’s intentions may be positive, this action could be perceived as performative and insensitive to the realities faced by women in that country.

Arguments For (with strong caveats):

  • Opportunity for Change (long-term): If the organization is committed to long-term engagement and social change, this assignment could potentially be a catalyst for positive change if it’s accompanied by a comprehensive strategy. This would involve careful preparation, ongoing support, and a commitment to addressing gender inequality within the subsidiary.
  • Empowerment (if done right): If the manager is fully aware of the challenges and chooses to accept the assignment, it could be a powerful statement of empowerment and resilience. However, this should never be presented as the only option for career advancement.

My Position:

I am against sending the female manager in this scenario without significant safeguards and a comprehensive strategy. Prioritizing her safety and well-being is paramount. Before considering such an assignment, the organization must:

  1. Conduct a Thorough Risk Assessment: Evaluate the potential risks to her safety and well-being.
  2. Provide Comprehensive Training and Support: Equip her with the skills and resources to navigate the cultural challenges she will face. This includes cultural sensitivity training, language training, and security awareness training.
  3. Establish Clear Communication Channels: Ensure she has access to support and can communicate any concerns or issues that arise.
  4. Develop a Strategy for Addressing Gender Inequality: This should be a long-term commitment and involve working with local partners to promote gender equality within the subsidiary.
  5. Obtain Her Informed Consent: She must be fully aware of the challenges and risks and must freely choose to accept the assignment. This should never be presented as the only path to career advancement.

Without these safeguards and a genuine commitment to addressing the underlying issues of gender inequality, sending a female manager to this environment would be unethical and irresponsible. It would prioritize the organization’s image over the well-being of its employee.

This question has been answered.

Get Answer

Is this question part of your Assignment?

We can help

Our aim is to help you get A+ grades on your Coursework.

We handle assignments in a multiplicity of subject areas including Admission Essays, General Essays, Case Studies, Coursework, Dissertations, Editing, Research Papers, and Research proposals

Header Button Label: Get Started NowGet Started Header Button Label: View writing samplesView writing samples