When you are faced with criminal prosecution, you could take your case to trial, or if offered, accept a plea bargain in exchange for a guilty plea. However, going to trial can be risky since the fate of that trial is in the hands of a jury, which will decide guilt or innocence. Most defendants will accept a plea agreement rather than taking the risk of a jury trial.
Explain a few of the pros and cons of plea bargaining for the defense attorney, prosecution, judge, and of course, the defendant?
In your opinion, are some defendants coerced into accepting a plea deal? Explain why/why not
Sample Answer
Plea bargaining is a negotiation process between the prosecution and the defense in which the defendant agrees to plead guilty to a lesser charge in exchange for a reduced sentence. Plea bargaining is a common practice in the United States, with over 90% of criminal cases ending in a plea bargain.
Pros and cons of plea bargaining for the defendant:
- Pros:
- Defendants who accept plea bargains are more likely to receive a shorter sentence than if they were convicted at trial.
- Defendants may be able to avoid the stigma and publicity of a trial.
- Defendants may be able to avoid the possibility of a longer sentence if they are found guilty at trial.
- Cons:
- Defendants who accept plea bargains give up their right to a trial by jury.
- Defendants may feel pressured to accept a plea bargain, even if they believe they are innocent.
- Defendants may have difficulty finding employment or housing after pleading guilty to a crime.
Full Answer Section
Pros and cons of plea bargaining for the prosecution:
- Pros:
- Plea bargaining allows prosecutors to resolve cases quickly and efficiently.
- Plea bargaining allows prosecutors to secure convictions in cases where they may not have been able to win a trial.
- Plea bargaining allows prosecutors to save resources that would otherwise be spent on trials.
- Cons:
- Prosecutors may feel pressured to offer plea bargains in cases where they believe the defendant is guilty of a more serious crime.
- Plea bargaining may allow dangerous criminals to avoid harsher sentences.
- Plea bargaining may erode public confidence in the criminal justice system.
Pros and cons of plea bargaining for the judge:
- Pros:
- Plea bargaining allows judges to resolve cases quickly and efficiently.
- Plea bargaining allows judges to avoid the uncertainty of a jury trial.
- Plea bargaining allows judges to focus on cases that are more likely to go to trial.
- Cons:
- Judges may feel pressured to approve plea bargains, even if they believe the defendant should receive a harsher sentence.
- Plea bargaining may allow dangerous criminals to avoid harsher sentences.
- Plea bargaining may erode public confidence in the criminal justice system.
Are some defendants coerced into accepting a plea deal?
Yes, some defendants are coerced into accepting a plea deal. This can happen in a number of ways. For example, a defendant may be threatened with a harsher sentence if they go to trial. Or, a defendant may be pressured to accept a plea bargain because they cannot afford to bail out of jail and go to trial.
In addition, defendants who are represented by public defenders may feel pressured to accept a plea bargain because their public defender has a heavy caseload and does not have enough time to prepare for trial.
It is important to note that plea bargaining is a complex issue with no easy answers. There are both pros and cons to plea bargaining for all parties involved. Defendants should carefully consider all of the factors involved before accepting a plea bargain.
If you are facing criminal charges, it is important to consult with an experienced criminal defense attorney to discuss your options. A good criminal defense attorney can help you to understand your rights and to negotiate a plea bargain that is in your best interests.
This question has been answered.
Get Answer
